Thursday, March 13, 2014

Forty years of memories



Do you know where you were on this date, forty years ago? I do. I was a young, senior zoo keeper hired the previous fall as one of the original keepers for the new Metro Toronto Zoo. According to my diary entry for March 13th, 1974, I was helping TB test 17 white-tailed deer. The operation was part of a bigger challenge that began on 8 January 1974 when a female blackbuck antelope died of tuberculosis (TB) in our outdoor holding facility. This began a long-running quarantine and numerous TB tests of the animals – and of the keepers, since TB is one of the many zoonotic diseases that can be passed between animals and humans.
The Tuberculin skin tests that I saw used consisted of an intradermal injection of a tiny amount of purified culture filtrate of Bovine TB under the skin in such a manner that a pea-sized bump was produced. After 2-days, the vet would need to inspect the site of the injection to see what, if any, reaction had occurred. If the test was positive, we would see what appeared to be an allergic reaction – redness and marked swelling – at the site of the injection. In hoofed stock, finding a bare patch of skin can be a challenge. In most cases, the veterinarians preferred the bare patch of skin under the tail around the anus, an area known as the Caudal Fold. A test in this area was not visible unless the animal was caught a second time to have the tail raised for a visual inspection. Another site for testing was in the skin of the upper eyelid. This method was almost always used in primates, and on a few occasions in hoofed stock. The results of the eyelid test were obvious without a second capture. One of the challenges is that a positive reaction does not necessarily mean they have TB, just that they have been exposed to it and have antibodies in their system. Diagnosis based on these clinical signs alone is very difficult, even in advanced cases.
All of the animals in the areas that had housed the blackbuck had to be tested, so on Monday, March 4th, 1974, we began the testing with a male wapiti (elk) and a male roe deer. The following day we caught and tested four reindeer, two muntjac, and seven Chinese water deer. All of these animals tested negative when they were caught-up two days later. The next Monday, on March 11th, we tested seven yak, three tahr, and one male barasinga deer. The female barasinga, according to my notes, was not tested because “the dart glanced off front knee” – meaning she did not go down. The following day we tested ten white-tailed deer and the female barasinga deer and on Wednesday, we tested seventeen more white-tailed deer.
The method of catching and restraining these animals varied. The larger and the more “flighty” animals were shot with tranquilizer darts. Some of the animals could be cornered and physically grabbed and restrained while others were caught in large hoop-nets. Of the ten deer we caught on Tuesday, for example, my notes say we caught two by hand, four in nets, and four of them were tranquilized. These procedures did not always go as planned. One of the white-tailed deer jumped into the pen next door that housed the Pere Davis’s deer and, on two occasions, deer jumped out of their pen and into a perimeter area in which they were still contained.
On Monday, March 18th, we tested eight blackbuck and, on Thursday of that week, we tested six Pere David’s deer and one mule deer. After nearly three weeks, we had caught, tested, and read the results on nearly seventy animals, which equals 140 captures with remarkably few casualties. All animals to this point tested negative.
On Tuesday, April 30th, our luck changed. We tested a male and three female European bison and when the tests were read on Friday, the male’s test was “suspect” and one of the females was positive. They were re-tested the following week with a more sensitive test in the eyelid instead of under the tail, and the male and two of the females were positive. We had not seen any signs of tuberculosis since the initial diagnoses in the female blackbuck, but now we were in for a long period of quarantine, treatments and endless testing. Unfortunately, I was transferred to a different area and have no record of what happened afterwards.
1974 was an eventful year for me. My two little boys, Mike and Jason were just 2 ½ years and 10 months old respectively. We had moved from the balmy, gulf coast of Florida to spend our first winter in Canada and I was in the midst of opening one of the largest zoo operations in the world. For a zookeeper, much of the work can be mundane – cleaning cages and feeding animals – but there was nothing mundane about those early days at the Toronto Zoo. We received new animals on a weekly basis – many of which I had never even heard of. We were catching, crating, uncrating, and moving animals around on a daily basis and, at one point, I found myself on a Polish freighter in the middle of the North Atlantic with a load of animals bound for Canada. So from now until the 40th anniversary of the opening of the zoo in August, I would like to remember some of those times.

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

A Sad Day at the Zoo



Marius was only two years old when he was killed. News reports disagree as to whether it was with a bolt gun or a rifle, but the young giraffe was considered surplus to the population – at least the population of the Copenhagen Zoo and the rest of the accredited zoos in Europe. My heart sank when I saw the report. Is this how zoos are supposed to operate? Not any zoo I know. Not my zoo.
I am not a hypocrite. I have been in the business of running zoos for more than forty years. I do eat meat and recognize that cattle are slaughtered every day to satisfy our needs. I have seen plenty of animals euthanized. It is as much a part of the zoo business as it is that of a veterinary practice. And the practical side of the Copenhagen Zoo’s case was that euthanizing the animal without chemicals made two hundred kilograms of meat available for the hungry carnivores, like some efficiency or “circle of life” argument.
I also recognize the potential educational opportunity. As a Copenhagen Zoo spokesman said in an interview with the Associated Press, "I'm actually proud because I think we have given children a huge understanding of the anatomy of a giraffe that they wouldn't have had from watching a giraffe in a photo".
That may be true, but what about the worldwide damage to the public perception of zoos? The LA Times correctly noted in a recent editorial that, “the action, and the explanation, cast a harsh spotlight on the role of zoos, a role that is increasingly being questioned as we learn more about wild animals and their difficulties in captivity.”  The editors go on to observe that “more than ever, zoos are taking responsibility for the well-being of their animals, which means keeping them alive and healthy as long as possible. That's not what happened here. And what lesson does it teach the public about respecting and admiring wild animals when that education includes the killing and dismemberment of an animal?”
The Associated Press reports that animal rights organizations around the world are now claiming “the case highlights what it believes zoos do to animals regularly”.
"It is no secret that animals are killed when there is no longer space, or if the animals don't have genes that are interesting enough," said one organization. "The only way to stop this is to not visit zoos."
A spokeswoman for People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) in the U.K. said Marius' case should serve as a wake-up call for anyone who "still harbors the illusion that zoos serve any purpose beyond incarcerating intelligent animals for profit."
This whole business makes me sad – sad for the giraffe, sad for my own sense of having been let down by my profession, and sad for those thousands (or millions) of people who think this is how zoos operate. According to CNN, “numerous American zoos did not immediately respond to requests for interviews”. The Association of Zoos and Aquariums (AZA) also declined a request, issuing a short statement stating that European zoo "programs and procedures vary from those of the AZA." It seems to me that no response is akin to tacit approval.
I am sorry, but I can’t stand by and say nothing. I feel that zoo animals are more like our pets than they are farm animals. We celebrate their births, give them cute names, and commemorate their birthdays every year. We talk about the urgency of our conservation work and how we are the best hope to save animals from extinction. Surely we can’t think it is OK to shoot them and slaughter them for meat at the end of the day. After all the good work zoos have done over the years, and all of the heart and soul that zookeepers put into giving the highest standards of care (and, yes, love) to their animals, we have handed a perfect argument to our critics who claim the true purpose of zoos is “incarcerating intelligent animals for profit". What a shame.
The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated.   Gandhi

Tuesday, December 17, 2013

The case for animal welfare



According to an article in sciencemag.org, three lawsuits filed last week that attempted to achieve “legal personhood” for chimpanzees have been struck down. They were the first step in a nationwide campaign to grant legal rights to a variety of animals. The Nonhuman Rights Project (NHRP) Executive Director Natalie Prosin tells ScienceInsider that her group expected this outcome. “We were pleasantly surprised at how respectful the judges were, specifically the two that allowed us to have oral hearings,” she says. “We were thrilled to be able to do that. Now we have something on record that we can take to appeals court.” She says her group is now preparing those appeals, which she hopes will be heard in about a year.
The author of an article in spiked-online.com disagrees, saying that even accepting a certain, limited capacity for cognition and emotion, chimpanzees can never be persons. A chimpanzee will never represent himself in court and demand his autonomy. A chimpanzee will never take on a job, walk into a store and make a purchase. A chimpanzee will never even express disdain at all the rubbish on TV. Chimpanzees will merely go on doing what chimpanzees have always done because they lack the scope for flexibility and engagement in anything beyond their spontaneous desires and immediate environment. Someone, the author says, should let the NHRP know that significant social change requires social and political engagement, not the swift turn of a judge’s gavel.
I have worked with animals all of my adult life and I have come to believe that it is not so much about the rights of animals as it is about our responsibilities as humans and as stewards of the planet. Societies decide what is right and what is wrong, and we create laws to prohibit the wrong. Keeping a chimp in a small cage is just plain wrong and should be prohibited by law.  Does that mean chimps should never be kept in any sort of confinement? Probably not. Does that mean no animals should be kept in confinement? There are many gray areas to be sure, but the sooner we begin to focus on animal welfare and stop arguing animal rights, the sooner we will get to an acceptable answer.
Richard Cupp, a law professor at Pepperdine University in Malibu, California, is a proponent of focusing on animal welfare rather than animal rights. “Animals are not persons,” he is quoted as saying in the article in sciencemag.org, “but that does not mean that abusing them is acceptable. Both humans and animals would be best served by placing a strong emphasis on human responsibility for humane treatment of animals rather than creating an artificial construct of animal personhood."
In an article for the Toledo Blade newspaper in 1997, syndicated columnist Thomas Sowell put it this way. “The mush-headedness of our times is nowhere better illustrated than in the ‘animal rights’ movement. Animals have no rights because they have no responsibilities and are not part of our legal system. Being against cruelty to animals is one thing, talking nonsense is another.”

Tuesday, November 5, 2013

The inescapable cruelty of life



When the Dallas Safari Club recently announced its plans to auction a hunt for a black rhinoceros in Namibia I knew that I, as a conservationist, should be outraged – but I was not. The permit to be auctioned at the Dallas Safari Club’s January convention could bring as much as one million dollars for Namibia’s Ministry of Environment and Tourism rhino program. Only an old, post-breeding bull will be targeted. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service says science supports the idea that limited culls of older males can benefit a local population and calls Namibia’s rhino program outstanding. The World Wildlife Fund also endorses the concept of selectively removing old male rhinos.
The announcement did touch off a firestorm of controversy in some mainstream conservation circles. According to a recent article in the Dallas Morning News, Wayne Pacelle of the Humane Society of the United States said the idea of auctioning a rhino hunt at a time when the world is mobilizing to save the animals from mercenary poaching is wrong. “Education,” he said, “is the key to saving threatened wildlife.”
Well that may be true, but money is still a powerful influence. Maybe I am less averse to this hunt because I live in an agrarian, hunting society in South Georgia. I have plenty of friends and colleagues who kill deer every year, not just for the sport of it, but also to put meat in the freezer. Hunters pump millions of dollars into the economy of saving wildlife habitat, something the “conservationists” are not able to do.
Kentucky-based poet, novelist, and farmer Wendell Berry was recently interviewed by journalist Bill Moyers for a segment of Moyers & Company. Berry, who is widely respected in conservation circles, spoke about “the inescapable cruelty of life”.
“Whether we like it or not,” he said, “we live at the expense of other creatures. The rule in using other creatures (both plants and animals) is to use them with the minimal amount of violence.”
In his poem For the Hog Killing, Berry’s respect for the process of butchering a hog is eloquently explained:
Let them stand still for the bullet, and stare the shooter in the eye,
Let them die while the sound of the shot is in the air, let them die as they fall,
Let the jugular blood spring hot to the knife, let its freshet be full,
Let this day begin again the change of hogs into people, not the other way around,
For today we celebrate again our lives’ wedding with the world,
For by our hunger, by this provisioning, we renew the bond.

The process of selectively removing an old male rhino from the population is a sound management practice. If that process can be utilized to benefit the general population financially then I might put that down to “the inescapable cruelty of life”.  I must admit, however, that I do find it distasteful that this rhino will end up a trophy, with his head hanging on some rich guy’s wall. I just hope the money is put to good use in Africa and doesn’t end up lining the pockets of some corrupt dictator. That would be the ultimate cruelty.

Saturday, October 5, 2013

Bigfoot and the Rewilding of Kentucky



In a recent (9/27/2013) TED Radio Hour Podcast entitled Everything is Connected, I heard an interview with author of the book Feral, George Monbiot. He talks about stumbling across the word “Rewilding” which, according to the website of the Rewilding Institute means “the scientific argument for restoring big wilderness based on the regulatory roles of large predators”. This is what we have seen in the Yellowstone ecosystem with the return of timber wolves. Monbiot claims in the interview that profound changes have occurred to the entire ecosystem as a result of the reintroduction of the wolves. The natural reduction of the deer and elk populations resulted in regeneration of plant life, leading to an increase in populations of birds, beavers, and bears and, most remarkable, the “behavior” of the rivers and streams. More plant life meant less erosion causing channels to change course and become more fixed. The reintroduction of wolves, he claims, changed the physical geography of Yellowstone. Who would have thought?
Monbiot is a huge advocate for rewilding. He lost me when he began talking about reintroducing rhinos, hippos, and lions to Europe and the UK – because fossilized bones indicate that they had once lived there – but then he went on to say something that really caught my attention. In talking about his desire for us to step back and let nature decide, he said rewilding is about the future and the hope of bringing back lost species, while much of our modern conservation work is about the past and trying to lock-in past ecosystems as we know them now. Rewilding, he says, gives us hope where we currently have despair. We need to replace the “Silent Spring” with a “Raucous Summer”.
All of this was rattling around my brain when I saw the news headline about the discovery of Bigfoot in Kentucky. A veterinarian, who leads something called the Sasquatch Genome Project, has been conducting an analysis of DNA samples she has collected and concludes that Sasquatch is a human relative that arose about 13,000 years ago. Unfortunately, while the Sasquatch Genome Project claimed in a February report to have submitted 113 samples of hair, blood, saliva and other tissues to laboratories, including New York University, NYU officials say they never accepted samples. A professor at the Department of Anthropology at NYU, told ABCNews.com that the research was "just a joke."
So, is it hope I felt when a small voice deep within my emotional self tried to tell my rational self that, with the Sasquatch Genome Project on the case, Bigfoot might be real?
“It’s a JOKE,” says my rational self. “But let’s release some timber wolves into the area and find out once and for all.”
Now there’s a Rewilding project to give us some hope!